Skip to main content

Frozen in Time: Voids as Pristine Laboratories of Physics

Why cosmic voids matter: pristine evolution

Nico Schuster, Nico Hamaus, Alice Pisani, Klaus Dolag & Jochen Weller
Key figure for Frozen in Time: Voids as Pristine Laboratories of Physics

The history of the universe is a tug-of-war between the attractive force of gravity and the repulsive push of dark energy. While galaxies and clusters are defined by chaotic mergers and rapid gravitational growth, cosmic voids are the emptiest regions of space and the first places where gravity loses this battle. This makes them a unique window into exactly how and when cosmic expansion takes over.

To uncover this transition, we utilized state-of-the-art cosmological simulations to trace the life cycle and evolution of these underdense regions across 12.5 billion years of history. By categorizing voids based on their relative rank within their population rather than their absolute physical size, we successfully mitigated the selection biases introduced by galaxy formation that otherwise can lead to counterintuitive results. Through this relative framework, we discovered that void evolution is not a continuous process of emptying out. Instead, once the universe reaches a certain age, these structures settle into a calm and stable state, passively following the expansion of the cosmos.

This stabilization is clearly visible in the image above. While the dark matter densities on the left side show an expected evolution, with densities inside voids decreasing as matter evacuates and accumulates at their boundary, the densities of halos (our proxies for visible galaxies) on the right remain remarkably stable over time. Moreover, we also discovered that the expected evolution of dark matter densities can be reliably predicted with simple linear growth theory. Small deviations still persist, but these may point toward interpreting voids as ‘separate universes’ that exhibit a naturally earlier and more potent dark energy onset.

Ultimately, these stable voids offer an exquisite and reliable window into the nature of dark energy, paving the way for more accurate measurements of the accelerated expansion of the cosmos.

Official abstract
We utilize the Magneticum suite of hydrodynamical simulations to investigate the formation and evolution of cosmic voids from \( z = 5.04 \) to present day, using cold dark matter and (sub-)halo tracers in high-density samples. This includes the evolution of their global properties, such as size, shape, inner density, and average density, as well as their radial density profiles. Our results provide several key conclusions for void analyses in modern surveys. We demonstrate that a relative framework, which bins voids by their size percentile rather than absolute size, is required to mitigate selection effects and restore the true physical evolution of halo-defined voids. This confirms that void properties are more fundamentally tied to their rank within the contemporary population than to their size. Using this framework, we show that the evolution of halo voids stabilizes at redshifts below \( z \simeq 1 \), driven primarily by cosmic expansion rather than ongoing halo formation. We further find that the matter evolution around these stable voids is remarkably well-described by linear growth theory. However, deviations appear as non-linear growth on small scales and suppressed growth in the largest voids, potentially driven by a higher effective \( \Omega_\Lambda \) and lower effective \( \Omega_\mathrm{m} \) within the separate universe picture. This late-time stability and the predictable evolution confirm voids as pristine laboratories for probing the nature of dark energy with upcoming surveys.